Mellow. Such a lovely word. What makes you mellow? For me, it’s driving. Preferably without a child in the backseat, or at least a sleeping child. There’s just something about hitting the open road that is good for my heart and soul.Can’t we all use a little more of this wonderful quality in our lives?
And isn’t this one of the characteristics that we all want for our kids? To be free from the problems of depression and anxiety and able to navigate life’s ups and down without undue stress. To have the ability to regulate emotions to be confident, happy adults?
Mellow? Yes please.
Today’s post talks about what we can do as parents to guide our kids through their upsets and anger, and towards mellowness. The analogy of driving through life just seems to fit this topic, so I hope you’ll excuse my comparisons!
Learning to Drive Our Emotional Cars
Having experienced a depression myself in my 20s, I want emotional health for my 3 year old son, Onetime, above all other things. I am determined to do everything (in my power) to help him grow up to be free from depression and unnecessary anxiety. To me that means him growing up understanding his emotions and how to handle them without becoming overwhelmed.
And here’s where the analogy comes in. In a way, we each have our own emotional “cars” we need to learn how to drive on the road of life. Some cars go fast and take in the scenery really quickly, while others take their time and really see the view. But all drivers need to learn to drive their own car, so it doesn’t get out of control and crash.
For myself, to learn how to drive my car, I needed to do a lot of reading, talking, and reflecting. In the course of my quest for understanding, I learned how depression is often the result not of being “too emotional” a person (something I’ve been told way too many times!), but a result of keeping negative emotions suppressed for far too long.
That was definitely me, to most of my peers I appeared to be quite happy and cheerful, but inside I was sad and angry and often felt misunderstood. I didn’t know how to release my negative emotions and move through them. I felt stuck, and after a while, it caught up with me and I became depressed.
One common experience that depressed and anxious people have is that the sad or anxious feelings seem like they will never go away. This of course, is not true, but is a really painful thought. Kids need to be taught that emotions are not something to be feared or suppressed, but are temporary and will pass if released.
Temper Tantrums: Releasing Upset Feelings
How they are released is probably quite familiar to you if you have a young child. Crying, shouting, hiding, hitting, and temper tantrums are all ways that children release their sadness, anger, and hurts. The behaviours just differ in intensity with different personalities and temperaments.
According to Lawrence J. Cohen, author of Playful Parenting, conveying to kids that certain emotions are inappropriate to express, leads to the feelings being suppressed. The problem is, they don’t disappear, they just get pushed down. For example, in many families, girls are discouraged from expressing anger and boys are discouraged from expressing sadness.
Unfortunately, when the feelings are suppressed, they tend to explode later in a torrent (translation: temper tantrum), OR kids start showing signs of internal stress (ie. biting nails, hitting their head on the floor or wall, twirling hair), and may become anxious, violent, or depressed. In their teens, they may start experimenting with drugs or drinking to try and numb those feelings. Pretty grim huh?
If kids don’t learn to drive their cars, and release their negative emotions in a healthy way – they are on the road to big problems. Suddenly the road ahead seems treacherous, instead of something that can be dealt with.
Fortunately, many of my favourite parenting experts address these issues and how parents can help kids learn to deal with their strong negative emotions.
Positive Parenting Approaches to Help Upset Kids
Faber and Mazlish, authors of How to Talk So Kids Will Listen & Listen So Kids Will Talk, talk about the importance of acknowledging our kids’ feelings when they are upset or angry. They put this topic as the first chapter of their book, because they recognize how critical this skill is in communicating with, and parenting, our children.
Kids need to feel that their parents care about and understand their feelings. In fact, when in the throws of a negative emotion, it is impossible for many kids to listen to advice, or reason, or react positively until those feelings are acknowledged.
It’s like the battery is disconnected!
Pam Leo, author of Connection Parenting, talks about how kids have a metaphorical “hurts cup” and a “love cup.” Hurts build up on a daily basis (more quickly for sensitive kids) and can overflow once they reach a certain point (again, think: temper tantrums). When a child’s hurts cup is empty and their love cup is full, they feel their happiest and most mellow!
The trick to helping them keep their hurts cup empty is to acknowledge the child’s negative feelings and to allow kids to release them without scolding, shaming, denying, downplaying, or otherwise impeding the release of the negative feelings.
If negative emotions are released regularly, they aren’t as likely to build up and overflow at unexpected times. Kids then learn the important life lesson that negative emotions are temporary and once released, they can feel much better and be able to solve their own problems and handle life’s disappointments again. Suddenly, negative feelings aren’t so scary anymore.
Keeping these things in mind, here are 8 ways you can support an upset child so that they can move through the negative feelings into a state of mellowness! Aw…yes!
8 Ways to Support an Upset Child
1. Acknowledge the child’s feelings.
Basically, tell the child that you see how they are feeling. “I see you are really upset/angry/embarassed.” Yes – it’s that simple! Looking for other examples? Check out our earlier post B is for Behaved.
2. Accept the child’s negative emotions.
This is not so much something you do, as an attitude you hold about your child’s expressing their feelings. If you can accept that expressing negative emotions is a part of being emotionally healthy (and a part of being human!), your child will sense this too.
3. Empathize with the child.
Sometimes this one is very difficult to do. According to Naomi Aldort, author of Raising Our Children, if you yourself have a difficult time expressing negative emotions, or were taught to suppress them, it can be very difficult to accept them in someone else – especially from a child where they tend to come out so raw. This is part of the reason why men, who often grow up being discouraged from showing sadness, often find it difficult to listen to a crying baby.
When Onetime was an infant I found it almost unbearable to hear him cry and I would do just about anything to get him to stop – cuddle him, nurse him, dance around the room snuggling for hours until he would settle. And that’s what Mother Nature intended when she designed the unique joy of a baby’s cry (I hope you know I’m being sarcastic here.)
It’s no different when kids get older. Kids still need us to be there and be supportive of their negative feelings – even if we don’t understand what caused them, even if it’s an inconvenient time, and even if they make us feel upset or uncomfortable (isn’t that just our issue to deal with – not theirs?)
4. Stay close.
When kids are sent to their rooms because they are upset, or otherwise excluded from being in our presence, they learn they have to deal with the emotions themselves. According to Lawrence J. Cohen, this essentially leads to kids feeling abandoned, isolated and powerless over their feelings. Quite the opposite of how we probably want them to feel.
5. Allow kids to cry.
Yes – even boys. I will never forget the time when I was walking around the neighbourhood with Onetime as a baby, and I overheard a conversation between 3 young boys about age 6, who were playing hockey. One of the boys had just taken a puck in the stomach and was doubled over and crying in the driveway.
A second boy looked alarmed, but just stood there. The third boy walked over and announced in a very loud voice, clearly mimicking something he had been told many times, “Get up! Boys don’t cry!” and he pushed the hurt boy over.
I was flabbergasted! I had certainly seen this kind of behaviour on the playground as a teacher, but not in boys so young. I looked down into the sweet face of Onetime, only a couple of months old, and swore that he would not become a boy like that.
In my opinion, there is no reason why being a man has to mean that expressions of hurt and empathy are suppressed. In fact, I believe that some of our society’s strongest men are the ones that are able to confidently express their emotions and find strength in them.
6. Follow the child’s cues for space.
After acknowledging and accepting a child’s feelings, he or she may still be quite upset. Then what do you do?
Some children really like a hug at this point, and after a few minutes of a nice hug or rocking, everything is better.
Then there are those kids that really DON’T want a hug. When I was working with troubled teens years ago as a behaviour therapist, we learned how important it is to follow the child’s cues with this.
For some kids, a hug feels like being crowded and can actually make things worse. In any case, offer a hug and your child will tell you what they want. Remember, stay close anyway.
7. Wait it out.
Whether you’re hugging it out, or just sitting nearby, sometimes this is all you can do until all those emotions have poured out.
8. Reconnect when it’s all over.
Eventually, when your child is feeling better – you will see a physical difference in their demeanor. They will be much more relaxed. And they should feel much better themselves too.
Don’t you after a good cry?
Now is a good time to do something pleasant together to connect. There are some great ideas in this post 30 Joyful Ways to Connect With Your Child.
A Perfect Storm
As an aside, it’s important to know ahead of time that sometimes doing these 8 things will nip the upset in the bud – and the storm will pass quickly. And sometimes, especially if this is a new way of responding to your child, the child may get even more upset than usual.
According to Dr. Cohen and Pam Leo, this reason for this is that once emotions start coming out, they can gain momentum, and pain from the past that was stored up or suppressed can start to come out too, as well as the current hurt. That’s why sometimes something as simple as a scraped knee can lead to an upset that appears to be out of proportion to the injury.
When all that negative emotion is finally out, kids are returned to equilibrium and will be pretty calm and mellow! Instead of wasting energy trying to stop the negative emotions, we can support their release – knowing that it is beneficial for kids to release them.
So how is this supposed to help our kids learn to regulate their emotions? Isn’t this just letting them lose control? Well, yes and no. It is through allowing emotions to be expressed, that kids learn eventually how to best regulate them.
The Road of Life
I think of it like this, if our body is an emotional car on the road of life, we need our kids to practice learning how to handle those curvy bumpy roads now before the mountains appear and the driving starts getting really tough!
Just think of all the curvy, death-defying roads of teen and adulthood.
If our kids are deprived of the chance to practise driving those difficult roads now, they aren’t going to learn the necessary skills to lean on as adults.
The more practice they get now, the better emotional drivers they’ll be! And because every child is driving a different car, they each need to find their own way of regulating themselves.
That’s why ways that we have developed ourselves, like exercising, talking with friends, finding “me” time, etc. are not necessarily what will work best for our child. It’s only through experience with their own car, that they will figure these things out.
Let’s be our kids’ best possible “driving” instructors. Let’s give them lots of hands-on practice on the road of life with a caring, supportive coach in the passenger seat. Hopefully, then we’ll be pointing them in the direction of a lifetime of mellow.
I would love to hear your thoughts about today’s post. Leave a comment below – they truly make my day!
To long winding roads with few accidents and dead-ends!
To find all my previous posts listed below, be sure to visit the Character Series page.
ciwin22 says
Absolutely fantastic post Sue, such brilliant advice. As a mom of a highly sensitive child I am constantly looking for gentle and effective ways of guiding him through his emotions and helping him to learn how to express them especially as he is starting school in 3 weeks time. Like you, more than anything I want emotional health and well being for my 2 children. Thank you so much for sharing this, it has been so helpful. Ciara
Sue Lively says
Thanks so much for dropping by Ciara. I’m glad you found some useful advice. I have found it so much easier to support my son when he’s upset after reading about these things. I know it will also help me in my teaching when I return in a year. So important for all kids to have someone recognize and accept their feelings – even the hard ones. Good luck with your guy in a few weeks. I hope he has a smooth transition – I know it can be a big change for little ones! Thanks again for sharing your thoughts! Best, Sue
Emma @ P is for Preschooler says
What a powerful post – maybe because I’ve struggled with depression, too, and also aim to let my daughter experience and learn to cope with her feelings freely. I’m never sure what a to do when she gets really upset though. I find that she likes me to sit with her, even if she’s crying on the bed, she wants me in the room, and eventually she comes over to sit with me and talk it out. I’m learning so much from this series!
Sue Lively says
Thanks so much for taking the time to comment Emma. It sounds like we’ve got similar goals for our kids and I’m glad you found this post useful. Even knowing all these things, it’s still hard for me to hear and see my son get so upset – it’s almost instinctual to try and help them feel better by DOING something, isn’t it? I have to remind myself (often) not to try and distract my son from his upset, and instead, patiently support. My son tends to need a lot of space when he’s upset, but I can always tell when he’s through the worst when he comes over and wants to hug. Since I started being more supportive with his upsets, I’ve noticed his desire to connect and snuggle more after it’s all done. I can TELL that what I’m doing is helping him. Hopefully, in the long run too. Thanks again for dropping by! Best, Sue
Vicky says
Hi I really enjoyed this read, I think my 4 yr old daughter is very emotional, tightly wound I say and it doesn’t take much for her to “freak out” I have been practicing muc of what you talked about for a while and find it works well, if she’s I full blown meltdown state I tell her I’m here for her when she’s ready for a hug and I acknowledge her emotion and agree with her feeling that way, my issue is when she actually says grrrrr I’m sooooo frustrated and kinda jerks around and stomps her feet usually at her brother, and it really can be over very silly things (I know u say to respect that this thing is causing them this emotion but really it’s silly stuff like her shoe is on the step or her brother accidentally touched her or her cup is the wrong color) this in writing sounds very appropriate but it’s very impractical in daily life so should I continue to let her do this? I guess my question is do we at least even offer “more acceptable” ways of expressing their emotions ??? Like I know you’re sad how about we xyz instead of hit? And she has this new found competitive streak where literally everything is a race or competition with her brother even who gets clicked out of car seat first then she gets sooooo frustrated or mad if it’s not her are u saying to just let her be and not make a big deal out of this behaviour that literally consumes us some days?? Thanks in advance
Vicky
Sue Lively says
Thanks so much for dropping by and taking the time to comment Vicky. It sounds like you have a sensitive daughter who experiences her feelings quite deeply. It’s going to take a lot of patience on your part to help her gradually learn to deal with her emotions and it sounds to me like you’re on the right track, although a challenging one!
What you wrote about how silly little things can trigger her upsets is a VERY common experience. Parenting experts, Pam Leo and Lawrence Cohen, both talk about how a small thing that is frustrating, can trigger a BIG reaction, because your daughter is letting out hurts that have been stored up during the day. It could have been some things that happened at preschool, or the fact that she’s overtired, or hungry, or countless other things that built up that you’re unaware of – they just all come pouring out when the “cup gets full” as Pam would say.
As you say, there is also so much more to say about helping kids deal with upsets that wasn’t covered in this post. My plan was to talk about aggression (both physical and verbal) in the upcoming posts of Social and eXpressive (this is an alphabetic series.) I am really hoping that you will stay tuned in and return to read those posts later.
Without going into too much detail now though, I would like to say that I hope I didn’t give the impression in this post that we should allow our kids to express their negative emotions through hitting, verbal attacks, or through threatening behaviour. Although these behaviours are natural ways for kids to express their emotions, they are never acceptable and as you say – kids need to be taught there are alternatives to expressing them that ARE appropriate. The Social and eXpressive posts will both touch on ways to teach these important skills.
For now, you’re lucky that your daughter is young enough that if she expresses herself by hitting or otherwise threatening behaviour, that you can act to physically STOP her behaviour, or at the very least – give her SPACE so she doesn’t hurt anyone (ie. ask brother to leave if you see her getting that upset). The BEST time to talk about these behaviours is AFTER you have acknowledged these feelings, and she has fully calmed down. Accept all emotions, NOT all behaviours.
As for her expressing herself using words – that is AWESOME! I would definitely encourage more of this. There are tons of 4 year olds who aren’t able to do that – you’ve obviously modelled and taught her well! Way to go Mama!
Thanks again for dropping by and I hope you’ll stay tuned for the rest of our series! Best, Sue
Kate says
I wonder what the evidence base is for the projected drug misuse etc of children not parented this way? Or any lins to mental health? I would be interested.
Sue Lively says
Thanks so much for dropping by and taking the time to read and comment Kate. I first became aware of the connection between childhood suppression of negative emotions and the possibility of this contributing to future anxiety/depression and drug use from Naomi Aldort’s book “Raising Our Children, Raising Ourselves.” We have to keep in mind that this is an extremely difficult connection to scientifically PROVE – there’s no way of actually controlling all the variables. However, strong correlations can be found. For example, there are many articles online that you can find that discuss how the suppression of emotion (especially anger) is a risk factor for poor mental health. Here’s a good one – http://www.webmd.com/anxiety-panic/guide/mental-health-managing-anger . The Mayo Clinic also reports that risk factors for drug use include a lack of attachment with parents, as well as anxiety and depression. Here’s their link – http://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/drug-addiction/basics/risk-factors/con-20020970 . I also found a specific study that concludes that a history of childhood emotional invalidation (i.e., psychological abuse and parental punishment, minimization, and distress in response to negative emotion) was associated with chronic emotional inhibition in adulthood and that this significantly predicted later psychological distress, including depression and anxiety symptoms. Here’s the link for that -http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0145213402005367 . Hope this helps! Happy reading. Best, Sue
Kate says
My other issue is from personal experience of playing with a child being parented this way. My younger toddler has been told he is hated by and physically intimidated by a 4 year old we know being encouraged to express his feelings freely. My child then watched the older child being hugged and told it was ok to feel that way. My two year old cried, then became very subdued. Discussing it later, he understood that he must have done something to cause the outburst and looked over the lovely afternoon we had had, deciding it must have been because he had played with the child’s toys. My question is, how do you manage the affect of your child’s freely expressed anger, frustration etc when it causes other children to feel scared, hurt, intimidated and / or distrustful of the child. How can the child being supported to negotiate social behaviour in the real world, taking care of others’ feelings? I’m concerned about the affect of this approach on the quality and opportunity for interaction with others if other children end up hurt and/ or frightened.
There is much in the approach that I utilise in my own parenting, such as acknowledgement and containment. However, this is certainly as part of a much wider approach.
Sue Lively says
Thanks so much for taking the time to comment Kate. You’ve brought up some really important points and pointed out some aspects that are missing from this post. It needs to be said that even though all emotions should be accepted and acknowledged, NOT all behaviours should be accepted. In my opinion, this child was struggling with anger and although his/her mom acknowledged that (Yay Mama!), there also needs to be a discussion about how to show that anger in an acceptable way. It’s not ever acceptable to physically intimidate another or to verbally express hate in that way – although these are typical child expressions. After acknowledging the child was upset, and waiting for him/her to calm down, this Mama could have taken advantage of a teachable moment. She could talk to her child about expressing anger in other appropriate ways. For example, she could have talked to her child about saying something like, “I need more space” or “I’m not done with that toy yet.” or “I’m upset with you.” or taught him/her to walk away next time. It can certainly be frustrating when your own child is on the receiving end of this kind of behaviour, and acknowledging that your own child is upset is also important here. I really hope you return to read this series Kate. I really appreciate your thoughtful comments. We will be covering some of the things that weren’t in this post with regards to teaching kids how to appropriately verbally express anger and upsets in our EXPRESSIVE post and how to deal with childhood aggression in our SOCIAL posts later in the series. Best, Sue
Tessa1 says
Thanks for your thoughtful replies. This is certainly the approach that I take, although I would be careful to make sure the other child was aware that the behaviour was not acceptable and would expect my child to make reparations following hateful aggression towards another. I think this is very important for both children.
Sue Lively says
Absolutely Tessa1. I couldn’t agree more about making it clear that the behaviours are unacceptable and about making reparation. I talk a bit about making amends in the E is for Empathy post in this series. Thanks so much for dropping by and taking the time to comment!
Alana says
So many wonderful, wonderful ideas here. Will share on my blog’s Facebook page!
Sue Lively says
Thanks Alana – glad you enjoyed reading! Best, Sue